• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Human Movement

Injury Rehab and Sports Performance Training, City of London

  • About
  • Process
    • Our Process
    • Muscle Activation Techniques
    • Resistance Training
  • Programmes
    • In person programme
    • Online programme
  • Resources
    • The Little Book of Injury Rehab
    • How to get strong and healthy past 50
  • Blog
  • Contact

Can you feel the tension?

October 22, 2014 by Paul

I used to be amazed by health care professionals who would diagnose a person’s movement problems by just watching them walk across the room.

Equally I would be very impressed when practitioners claimed they could feel tension in a muscle.

In a recent NOI post the idea that practitioners can be so precise as to not only feel tension within a muscle but to identify taught bands within specific muscle fibres is called into question. They point to a 2006 review study that showed only muscle endurance tests and symptom response tests have any significant reliability.

That is not to say that there aren’t practitioners out there with incredibly precise palpation skills, it’s just that decisions made as a result of those palpations may owe more to pareidolia than to anything quantifiable and repeatable.

If you push into tissue and feel more resistance in one area than in another, what does this represent anyway?

Every therapists favourite spot to push is on the top of the shoulders, usually into Upper Trapezius. Patient and practitioner alike normally hum in unison ‘that feels tight’.

Let’s do an experiment, try this and tell me what you feel. Sit with your shoulders slumped forwards in so called ‘bad posture’. Now push a couple of fingers into the top of your shoulders. How does that feel? Tight? Now sit up tall and drop your shoulders back. How does the same spot feel now? Looser?

What did we change?

The position of a few joints. The funny thing about the example above is that upper trapezius will help keep those shoulders back but not of course if you keep massaging the life out of it.

My point is this, pushing into an area of the body and making both a diagnosis and treatment plan based on how much resistance there is to your touch is not a reliable way to treat. Just as you can’t really decide what is wrong with somebody by watching them walk across a room.

Filed Under: Rehabilitation

Is sport healthy?
Muscle Activation Techniques for golf.

Primary Sidebar

The Little Book of Injury Rehab

Not making progress with your rehab?

Subscribe below and find out how to get moving with our FREE 21 page guide.

The Little Book of Injury Rehab pdf

Get strong and healthy past 50

Everything you need to know about exercise at 50 and beyond.

Subscribe and receive our 60 page guide FREE.

How to get strong and healthy past 50 pdf

Categories

Recent Posts

  • The German approach to back pain with an 88% success rate. February 2, 2023
  • Why most people aren’t strength training effectively (even if they think they are). January 22, 2023
  • Allostatic load and chronic injury rehab: Strategies for recovery. January 4, 2023
  • Rehab exercises causing you pain? Try this. December 2, 2022
  • Why the future of musculoskeletal health care must include resistance training. November 17, 2022

Footer

CONTACT

Human Movement
30 Cannon Street
London, EC4M 6XH

+44 020 7183 1164
paul@human-movement.com

BLOG

  • The German approach to back pain with an 88% success rate. February 2, 2023
  • Why most people aren’t strength training effectively (even if they think they are). January 22, 2023
  • Allostatic load and chronic injury rehab: Strategies for recovery. January 4, 2023

FOLLOW

SUBSCRIBE

Privacy | Cookies | Terms